Skip to main content

An Attachment to Detachment

I'm struggling with Sylvie and Ruth's philosophy about what it means to have a meaningful relationship with someone. 

I keep thinking about that part where Ruth describes watching a woman in a train travel by and questioning how that interaction was different than knowing a person. The conclusion Ruth seemed to come to (much through Sylvie's influence I presume) was that she didn't know that woman any less or more than anyone else in her life. This reminded me of the way Sylvie talks about people she meets once in a boxcar and never sees again. Sylvie doesn't say "I met a person," she says
"I knew a person," implying that "meeting" and "knowing" are indistinguishable in her world. Sylvie does not maintain long-term relationships with anyone except Ruth, who also adopts this transient lifestyle. Both Sylvie and Ruth revel in a solitude I imagine most readers struggle to comprehend, as it seems too rebellious, too isolated from the societal sphere to even consider trying out. 

I'm doing my best to have an open mind about what it means to have a fulfilling life. That being said, Sylvie and Ruth's preference for detachment is so unlike human nature that I can't help but wonder if it's a coping mechanism of some sort. Both women have suffered grave losses in their family, the most recent being Lucille's rejection and departure. Perhaps Sylvie believes that she's protecting herself by cutting ties before she gets emotionally invested in a relationship, for fear of getting hurt again. 

Relationships are also tied to specific places and times in one's life, and therefore contradict the philosophy of transience that defines Sylvie's existence. If she pursued a connection with someone, she'd have a social responsibility to visit them and keep in touch with them, and Sylvie doesn't seem like the kind of person to take any kind of responsibility seriously. 

On one level, I want to dig deeper into the reasons for Sylvie's attachment to detachment, if you will. On the other hand, I feel as if it is really none of my business. If Sylvie's not hurting herself or anyone else, she should be allowed to live however she pleases without scrutiny. 

Comments

  1. I agree, it's not really any of our business. But I do think that both Sylvie and Ruth have been abandoned by enough people to just simply imagine what we call "knowing" as a sort of phony and over-hyped way ot thinking about people. Based on their experience, can they say they really know anyone? People, even when you are close to them (which is different), are still only there for a bit, which really is more like "meeting". Meeting involves knowing, but without the connotation of an unrealistic expectation that comes with knowing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sylvie's transient relationships are certainly difficult for most of us to get our heads around. It's maybe fun and interesting to meet all kinds of eccentric people who have stories to tell, but most of us would distinguish such fleeting interactions from real "friendships," or instances where we "know" someone else. The daughters' sudden severing of ties with their mother might seem cruel and callous, and we might be inclined to pass judgment on Sylvie's *capacity* for love or friendship or commitment. I see what you're getting at when you ask who we are to judge, but in this novel, there is an urgency to the question of Sylvie's ability to cultivate a committed long-term relationship (her "marriage" is a total parody of the very idea). This urgency has to do with Ruth: how committed is Sylvie to Ruth by the end of the novel? Do we see them running away *together*, or is Sylvie running away and Ruth just comes with her? Ruth herself worries about this, and often feels like Sylvie wouldn't care one way or the other if she were there or not. But the extraordinary effort Sylvie puts into first trying to save the household and the family, and then executing this crazy plan to burn down the house and live off the grid suggests--to Ruth's surprise--that Sylvie cares more than Ruth has realized she does. The last words of the novel are "me and Sylvie," and we have every indication that the two of them have stayed together in this very unconventional domestic arrangement. We have to assume that Sylvie has developed a real and enduring connection to Ruth, solidified in their death-defying crossing of the bridge together.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

In Honor of International Women's Day...

This is a Dr. Nolan appreciation post because I don't think Esther could've survived her depressive episode without support from someone like Dr. Nolan. Firstly, Dr. Nolan tells it like it is. When Esther explains to Dr. Nolan why she hates shock therapy, Dr. Nolan quickly announces that Dr. Gordon "did it wrong." It is clear that Dr. Nolan knows the importance of her work and therefore doesn't have time (or respect) for people who do it wrong. Dr. Nolan is also extremely frank when talking to Esther. She doesn't sugar coat anything, making it clear that her road to recovery will be unpredictable. That being said. Dr. Nolan also does her best to address Esther's concerns head-on. For example, when Esther expresses her fear of having a baby (and therefore her hesitancy to be sexually active), Dr. Nolan sends her to a clinic to be prescribed birth control. Dr. Nolan doesn't make Esther feel bad for wanting to be sexually active before marriage or derai...

Harry Potter and the Black Swan Green

As I read Black Swan Green , I keep getting reminded of scenes in Harry Potter (my bible). However, I have now come to the realization that  Black Swan Green  and  Harry Potter are both a series of coming-of-age tropes that show up in countless novels throughout the history of literature. It just so happens that my introduction to the concept of coming-of-age was through the Harry Potter series, so that's what my brain jumps to when I read Black Swan Green. That being said, here are some connections I've made between the two novels, which are examples of much broader coming-of-age literary motifs. Madame Crommelynck reminds me so much of Dumbledore. An older mentor who has a somewhat inexplicable investment in a significantly younger boy who is struggling to navigate an unforgiving world? Seems like a decent comparison. There's also a mysterious air around Madame Crommelynck and Dumbledore. Both of them keep their cards close to their chests, only revealing details abou...

Everybody's Faking It (And That's Okay)

I'm really enjoying Sag Harbor. I think Whitehead is an incredibly witty, thoughtful writer who masterfully captures coming-of-age in all its forms. I know this because I don't have a whole lot in common with Benji on the surface. Yet, there are multiple scenes throughout this novel that have resonated deeply with my experiences growing up. One notable example is the scene where Benji sees two of his friends (I forget which ones) totally botch an impromptu handshake. This is a significant moment for Benji, as he sees The Handshake as a kind of secret code, a way of demonstrating your exclusive updatedness on black pop culture. Up until this point, Benji is under the impression that everyone in his friend group knows about the newest handshakes but him. He describes paying close attention to his friends at the beginning of the summer so he can quickly master the trendiest techniques, feigning coolness until he actually achieves it by the end of the summer (only to "lose...